The Official Supernatural: “Last Holiday” (15.14) Recap and Review

We need your help!

You can still find my reviews here of North Carolina ghost story books, and notes about my folklore research on Patreon. Contribute monthly via Patreon (which includes perks), make a one-time donation through Paypal, or buy us a coffee.

According to recent reports from Vancouver, the cast returned to work the first week of August (about two weeks late). Jensen Ackles also explained in a recent virtual “fan experience” through Creation Con that the writing for the last two episodes has been tweaked to reflect recent events (i.e., the Coronavirus pandemic). With these writers, I’m not sure if that’s a good thing or a bad thing. He also said that 15.19 will be a season finale, while 15.20 is more like a series finale (and expressed sadness on Instagram when he got the final script, which said “The End” instead of the usual “To Be Continued”). In an already truncated final season, that likely means we’ll get stuck with some filler clips episode as the last one. Yay.

This recap was a bit late (sorry), as I’m working on a Halloween Zoom talk about local ghost stories and legends in eastern North Carolina. It’s free and it will be October 25 at 7pm (EST), until 8:30pm. You can register beforehand (no obligation) here. I’m hoping to get the next recap and review up on time, but if not, we should get back on track after the talk.

You can find a promo, photos and a synopsis here for 15.15.

If you’re enjoying these articles and reviews, any contributions are welcome. Even in a pandemic, the kitties still gotta eat and I’ve got a house full of snarfly foster kittens with seasonal eye gunk right now. My kitty Goose is doing much better, thank you (she’s acting as if nothing happened now), but I’ve still got that bill, so every little bit helps.

Scroll down to find links to all of my recaps and reviews of all seasons up to this point.

Recap: Fairly quick (less than a minute) recap, considering the show just came off a major and final hellatus, of Cuthbert Sinclair and Abaddon in Season 9 (and to think I just reviewed those episodes), and Jack’s boring “got his soul back” storyline from the previous ep.

Cut to Now in the Bunker, where Sam is doing research, Dean is cooking burgers (in an apron), and Jack is still sulking in his room. Sam snarks about the apron, though hey, at least, we get a reprise of Dean the Great Cook. Dean has come out of the kitchen to note that the Bunker seems to be on the fritz. The pilot light in the kitchen keeps going out, and he and Sam both notice that things keep switching on and off. Dean complains that the Bunker is supposed to be “state of the art,” though Sam snarks that yes, it was, “for the Fifties.”

While that’s true, the Bunker was shut down for over half a century and possesses lower transistor tech than we have today. Low tech tends to be more durable than high tech. Also, the Bunker is magical.

Anyhoo, at that moment (after Dean asks where Jack is and Sam says he’s in his room), the air goes down. This is right after the Brothers talk about how Castiel is looking for Amara for them and they’re probably going to kill her (this still seems like a stupid plan to me. Why not talk to her, first?). Dean decides they need to do something about the air. Well, yes, since otherwise, they’re going to suffocate. Sam wonders what they can do.

Dean: We fought the Devil, okay? I killed Hitler. I think we can handle some old pipes.

Cut to the Brothers coming down into a control room we’ve never seen before and apparently, they haven’t, either. Sam found it after some research. There is a large old-time, very-active-looking control panel. This is a pretty big retcon, I gotta say, that the Brothers never even looked at this room (which was so easy to find) when they were reconnoitering the Bunker. I mean, come on, Show.

Anyhoo, Sam says all the basic stuff like water and pipes should be controlled from that panel and maybe they should call in a plumber. Dean laughs this off and makes a Mario Brothers joke. Among other controls we don’t get a good look at, the control panel has two big buttons in the lower right-hand corner of the panel. One says “Standby” and the other “Reset.” The Standby button is glowing. The Reset button is not.

Out loud, Dean notes that whenever the porn on his laptop gets too many pop-ups, he just reboots. So, he hits the Reset button right as Sam is arguing that’s not a good idea. Now, obviously, since this is the episode’s teaser, it’s a bad idea, but the writing to this point doesn’t quite justify that. I mean, you’ve got a Reset button and the system is glitchy. Wouldn’t hitting it at least be an option?

Anyhoo, everything goes dark for a moment, but then it comes right back up and the glitches go away. Crowing “Victory!” in a bad Italian accent, Dean goes back upstairs to continue cooking burgers.

Later, we see Dean enter his room with a finished “Dean Deluxe” burger (which looks very tasty). Suddenly, he looks up offscreen and backs up. Cut to his bed, where a middle-aged, red-haired woman is folding his underwear, including a pair of Scooby-Doo-themed shorts. She says, “Oh! Hello, dear.” Dean bellows for Sam.

Cue title cards.

Cut to the Library, where the woman is commenting on all the dust and “filth,” and Dean is saying “Who the hell are you, lady?!” (she comments on his “language”). It takes this long for Sam to arrive from wherever he was and he’s quite startled to meet the woman, as well. He asks her name. She says her “true name is indecipherable in your tongue,” but says that “Mr. Ganem called me Mrs. Butters.”

Sam susses out that she’s not human based on the “our tongue” comment, though that’s pretty obvious at this point. She says that she’s a “wood nymph.” Dean’s reaction face is epic. When Dean asks, “Well, shouldn’t you be in the woods, nymphing?” she calls that “a young one’s game.” Also, she “lives here.”

When Sam suggests she’s a Lady of Letters, she calls herself a “helper.” She basically acted as a live-in maid and nanny for the Men of Letters, who needed, you know, a woman around the house. Even if she wasn’t human.

Dean sarcastically calls this “very progressive” (since it obviously isn’t), then tells her she can “just leave.” This prompts confusion and bewilderment from Mrs. Butters. As she said before, the Bunker is her home and Dean is basically kicking her out. After all, she’s served the Men of Letters “since before the War.”

Confused, Sam asks her what year she thinks it is and she replies in a small voice, “1958?”

Dean rather bruskly breaks the news to her that it’s actually 2020. When she asks where all the Men of Letters are (Mr. Akers and Mr. Markham, specifically), while gesturing at a photo of them on the wall, Dean says she is looking at the only two left. The others are dead. He explains that Abaddon killed them and that she was a demon. Though fluffy, Mrs. Butters is a quick study and realizes this is why the Men of Letters never came back.

In a warm-tones flashback, she explains that when they went to their ceremony (the swearing-in ceremony for Josie and Henry, where Abaddon used Josie to ambush and murder almost all of the chapter), they left Mrs. Butters behind to guard the Bunker. When they didn’t return, she put the Bunker (and herself) into Standby mode. When she hit the button, the lights went down and she turned into green smoke that was sucked up into the glowing symbols on the walls.

The Brothers try to explain that they didn’t realize she was there and that they have been dealing “with one apocalypse after another.” Mrs. Butters is very understanding. Her “boys” dealt with the same kind of schedule. She says that it must have been “an age” since the Brothers had “a home-cooked meal or a holiday.” She takes a step forward, wrinkles her nose, and comments that they haven’t washed their clothes in a while, either. Sam admits they’re not that kind of people.

Dean realizes that the Bunker has been “at half-power” the entire time they’ve been there. Mrs. Butters confirms this and, snapping her fingers, brings the place up to full power. Seems her magic is used to power the place to a higher level. The lights brighten (and turn on in the telescope alcove) and a red spot on the map starts to beep. Mrs. Butters explains that’s the “monster radar.” Pressing the red dot, she gives them the exact location of a nest of vampires 50 miles away from the Bunker. And by that, I mean she gives them the street address. She tells them if they hurry, they can clean out the entire nest and be back for dinner.

Dean is thrilled that they’ve finally caught a break, but as Mrs. Butters goes off to dust up the other room, Sam wonders if they can trust her. Dean points out that the Men of Letters would have needed a creature like her to take care of them and one way to find out is to check out the nest. If she’s telling them the truth, they can go from there.

Sam asks what happens if she isn’t and Dean prosaically says, “Then we deal with her.” Sam then asks, “What about Jack?” Oh, sigh, and things were going so well up to this point.

Cut to Jack, moping in his room. Dean knocks on the door. He tells him they’re going out for a while and gives him a heads-up about Mrs. Butters. He says she’s “probably harmless,” but in case she isn’t, to give them a call. He also says she’s baking “snickerdoodles.” Oooer. Jack just mopes, because that’s Jack for you these days.

In the car, Sam is still worrying away at whether or not Mrs. Butters can be trusted. Sam doesn’t seem to realize that Dean is trusting, but verifying, not just taking Mrs. Butters at face value. The discussion quickly turns to Whether Jack Is Okay because of course it does [sigh] after Dean points out that Mrs. Butters isn’t that big of a deal when they have “the Son of Satan living down the hall.”

Sam wonders if Jack is okay, what with Chuck “deleting worlds” and Amara in the wind. After admitting that Jack, is “a mess,” Dean says, “He’ll be fine. I mean, I’ve been through worse. Look at me – I’m the picture of health.”

Sam: Ignoring your trauma doesn’t make you healthy.

Dean [insincerely]: Sure, it does.

Boy, it’s been a while since Dean’s mental health issues have come up.

Anyhoo, they table the discussion for now.

Back at the Bunker, Jack is still moping, so Mrs. Butters knocks on his door with a sandwich. When he won’t answer, she says she’s leaving it by the door (now that Jack has his soul back, does he have regular human cycles or are we ignoring all that?).

Meanwhile, the vampire nest mentioned before turns out to be two bearded hicks watching an old vampire movie (not sure which one) on a TV in a shack, while sucking down blood from a local blood bank in their Big Swig mugs. Just as one vampire is musing why they don’t get to live in a mansion like the vampire in the film, Sam and Dean kick down the door. The two lowlife vamps helpfully whip around and thrust their heads forward, fangs bared. So, the Brothers simultaneously whack off their heads at one blow.

“Monster radar rules!” crows Dean.

The Brothers return to the Bunker to find it decorated for Christmas. There’s a giant tree in the library, with a train running around it. A big band version of “Hark! The Herald Angels Sing!” is on the soundtrack (is that irony deliberate?). Mrs. Butters comes out, giggling, with a plate of cookies. Both Brothers are nonplussed at first, but Dean starts to get into it, while Sam looks constipated.

Dean: We are so keeping her!

Cut to Mrs. Butters giving Sam some pancakes and a pep talk the next morning about his rather dour look on the world. In comes Jack and suddenly, her mood changes. She immediately recognizes him as not-quite-human, saying “What. Are. You?” in a tense voice.

Dean comes in, wearing a purple nightshirt and hat. He’s very excited about it (it was a gift from Mrs. Butters) and thanks her. A horrified Sam gets an eyeful (seems Dean is not wearing underwear beneath the nightshirt when he lifts it up) and Dean somewhat defuses the situation by off-handedly vouching for Jack.

Mrs. Butters just-as-off-handedly acknowledges Dean’s thanks, while bristling at Jack. Eventually, she stands down and appears to accept him. Whipping up a smoothie out of nowhere, she gives it to him, even as he’s protesting that he’s not hungry. When Dean shows an interest in the smoothie, she gives him a tomato juice, instead, saying she’s “worried about your cholesterol.” Jack looks amused at Dean’s crestfallen reaction.

A buggy horn goes off overhead, and both Sam and Dean run to their rooms to get dressed. As they’re coming back out past the kitchen, Mrs. Butters hands them each a bag lunch (“no crusts”), tells Sam the monster is a Lamia and that’s she’s put “blessed knives in the trunk,” and tells him to tell Dean to use the Impala gently, since she just waxed it.

Jack wants to go along, but Sam tells him to stay behind and take it easy. They’ll be right back. After saying goodbye to Sam, Mrs. Butters turns back with an edged smile and says to Jack, “Well. What shall we do with you?” Jack smiles at her, not noticing the undertones. Later, she gets him to tell her about being Lucifer’s son, how TFW 2.0 are his only real family, and how he killed Mary in a fit of pique.

Mrs. Butters says, “We all do things, things we’re not proud of.” But she adds that life is full of “second chances,” then offers him another smoothie.

Cue an adorable montage to The Bus Boys’ “Cleanin’ Up the Town” (from Ghostbusters, of course) of the Brothers running off to a hunt (excitedly grabbing bag lunches from Mrs. Butters at the kitchen on the way out), busting down doors, and having holidays (Thanksgiving, Halloween, Fourth of July, and Sam’s birthday). In the last hunt, they blow the door to a shack open and Dean comes in with a rocket launcher, while Sam is hefting Mjolnir.

We come back out of the montage to Sam’s birthday. When Dean wonders if he can have some of the same Rice Krispies treats when he has a birthday, Mrs. Butters comments that she’s surprised that he would still want to celebrate his birthday (i.e., that he’s over 40), but then says she was just teasing and there is more for him in the kitchen.

I’m not sure why the writers continue with these stupid age jokes when they are literally old enough to know better. I get that they work for a network that caters to a young female demographic in an often problematical way that involves literally fetishizing young women, but come on.

Anyhoo, life goes on and Jack gets hooked on his smoothies. One night, he’s coming out with an empty glass when he finds Mrs. Butters in the library, furtively looking at a file in one of the cabinets while dusting. Looking pensive, she puts it back, then jumps and squeals when Jack calls her name. As she comes over, he asks her for another smoothie. Instead of just whipping one up, as she has before, she takes the empty glass and goes off to the kitchen to get him a refill.

This gives him a chance to look through the drawer she was looking in. He finds an old Manila envelope with a CLASSIFIED file inside. It includes her photo and an old film reel. He sneaks off down to the projection room and revs up the film (how he knows how to do this is glossed over).

The faded black-and-white film has an opening narration by Cuthbert Sinclair (whom we briefly met in “Blade Runners” when he tried to enslave Dean, the Mark of Cain, and the First Blade). He calls it File 5150. He then reveals that “Subject B, casually referred to as ‘Mrs. Butters,’” was “retrieved” by Man of Letters Henshaw from a Thule lab. So, it seems the Thule had originally enslaved her (she killed a battallion of 200 men before they could “restrain” her) and if she has been working with the Men of Letters since “before the War,” then the Men of the Letters and the Thule must have been fighting a shadow war with each other even before WWII.

Sinclair then goes on to theorize that even though wood nymphs are normally “docile, they react- violently when home or family are threatened.”

He then turns and we see he is in the dungeon. There is a hooded prisoner in a chair and standing behind the chair is Mrs. Butters, smiling inanely. He says he’s been doing “a series of experiments” (translation: magical torture) to convince Mrs. Butters to join the Men of Letters, “for safety and security.” Pulling off the prisoner’s hood, he reveals that the man in the chair is a Thule operative. Having already extracted all info possible out of the prisoner, Sinclair instructs Mrs. Butters to pull off his head. She does, with the same cheerful smile, then asks, “Would anyone like tea or cookies?”

Horrified, Jack exclaims, “Son of a bitch!”

Jack comes running out into the library shouting for Sam (why not Dean?). Mrs. Butters is there and says Sam will be out in a moment. He’s getting ready for a date with Eileen. Sam comes out in a rather old-style waistcoat and tie ensemble. He says he feels silly. Mrs. Butters assures him he looks great (well, yeah. For the 1950s). Though she would like to cut his hair (Sam demurs).

Dean comes out in his usual flannel, saying “Wow! Somebody’s shopping at Abercrombie and Bitch,” to which Mrs. Butters scolds him: “Language!”

Sam tells them that he’s going on a date with Eileen, who is in town. They are trying to rekindle things since their disastrous kidnapping by Chuck a few episodes ago. Dean figures Sam is going to get laid. Mrs. Butters whips up a bouquet of red roses for Sam and sends him off, though afterward, she scolds Dean for being so mean to Sam. Dean is not especially repentant. But he is happy when she tells him she fixed the TV in his room and runs off to check it out.

Instead of following Dean to talk to him, Jack decides to stalk Mrs. Butters, instead. Because that’s smart.

He follows her down into the storage room and dungeon, where he confronts her. Mrs. Butters, smiling, asks him how the film made him “feel.” Jack is thrown by this question, especially when she supplies an answer – that he “enjoyed” watching her kill the Thule.

Jack realizes that she set him up, that it was a test, and that she thinks he failed (her going off to the kitchen to make him a smoothie should have been his first clue). She says that if the Brothers knew how powerful he’s become, they’d be terrified of him and they should be, that maybe they keep Jack sequestered in the Bunker to keep him from murdering anyone else the way he did Mary.

Jack protests that he would never hurt Sam and Dean, but Mrs. Butters points out that he already has in the past – a whole lot. Then she TK’s him into a wall. Jack gets up and gets angry. He starts to power up, but his eye glow fritzes and fades. As Mrs. Butters slaps a pair of magical cuffs on him (not sure if they’re demon or angel or archangel, or what), she tells him that she used the smoothies to reduce his power. Now, he can’t do anything. Seems she learned a few things while dusting in the library. She pokes him in the chest and TK’s him again into the wall.

When Jack asks her why she’s doing this, she says, “To make the Bunker safe again. To kill all the monsters!”

I know the show wants us to side with Jack and see Mrs. Butters as dangerously out of control. But Mrs. Butters actually isn’t wrong. This scene is a classic case of When the Villain Has a Point.

The show seems to want us to believe that Jack has changed permanently for the good because he has his soul back. But Jack did plenty of horrible things when he had his soul (nor was he at all forgiving about, say, rescuing Dean after Dean said yes to alt-Michael to rectify Jack’s mistake, and save Sam and Jack from Jack’s father). and he intentionally lost his soul out of a desire to get his powers back. Thing is, every time Jack has had to choose between Sam and Dean, and getting his power back, he’s chosen power every time. So, I don’t think the writers did a convincing job of setting up the conflict here.

Dean comes out into the kitchen to see that Mrs. Butters has fixed him a grilled cheese sandwich. Just as Dean is happily digging into it, she tells him the food is to give him strength to go down to the dungeon and kill Jack. Then she hands him a brass dagger.

With a sad, longing look at the sandwich, Dean sets it aside, takes the dagger, and after a comment about how unfortunate it is that she turned “Nurse Ratched” on them, says they’ll go down to the dungeon, let Jack out, and “forget this ever happened.”

That gets him locked in the dungeon with Jack. Mrs. Butters insists that Dean has been “infected” by Jack, who is “just like his father … the Serpent in the Garden” (kind of ironic considering Jack was in the Garden just last episode). Sam returns from his date to find Mrs. Butters waiting for him. When he asks where the others are, she tells him that Jack has got inside Dean’s head, where the two of them are, and that he and she now have to go kill them. She calls him “the smart one” for figuring it out.

Sam says, sure, he’s just going to go to his room for his gun and meet her down there. Instead, he calls Dean from inside his room (apparently, there is cell phone reception in the dungeon, now). When Sam asks why Dean didn’t call him sooner, Dean says he didn’t want to bother him on his date: “It’s been a while for you, man” (truer words). Dean is oddly casual about the whole thing, as if it’s a minor inconvenience.

When Sam asks him for suggestions, Dean points out that Sam was going to research ways to stop Mrs. Butters if she turned evil and suggests shooting her. Sam protests that he’s been distracted by all the celebrations (they reminisce briefly over the fabulous omelette from Boxing Day). Dean suggests hitting the Standby button in the control room (which is actually quite a good idea) to shut her back down. Sam decides to try it.

Back in the dungeon, Jack suggests that he could use his powers to get them out of there, but Dean says the amount of power Jack would need to break out of the cuffs would alert Chuck to his presence (also, Jack’s powers have been reduced by all the smoothies, but it’s not clear if Dean knows about that, yet).

Jack starts panicking a little, saying he has a “mission.” When Dean tells him to calm down and turns away (trying to think), Jack quietly asks if Dean still thinks he’s a monster. Dean turns back to face Jack and lays it all out. He’s trying to forgive Jack, but it’s hard. On the other hand, he’s not “going to let some evil Mary Poppins take you out.”

Upstairs, Sam is edging through the library, gun in hand, calling for Mrs. Butters. When she appears, he does try to shoot her, but she stops him with TK and then TK’s him into a chair. She merrily tells how Sinclair “explained” the importance of the Bunker to her and since Sam is her “favorite,” she’s not going to give up on him … yet. She then proceeds to show him how Sinclair “explained” things to him – by ripping out his fingernails, one by one. Has that happened to Sam since Season 3’s “A Very Supernatural Christmas”? I think so, but can’t recall the other episode.

No matter what Sam tries to tell Mrs. Butters about Jack being “just a kid,” she insists that Jack is a monster who will kill them and she’s already lost her previous team to a monster. She’s not doing it again.

In the dungeon, Dean has an idea, but it involves some rather brutal methods (a very old piece of soundtrack plays over this – I think it’s “Lilith Unfair.” No, sorry, it’s “Old ‘Monster Movie’”). He’s going to use the brass knife to try to break the chain between the cuffs. Jack isn’t too sure it’s going to work and Dean is cheerily unreassuring about the whole thing. When he hits the cuffs with the knife, the magical blowback tosses Jack against a cabinet, smashing it. Dean says the cuffs aren’t coming off without a key, but he’s got another idea (especially since it seems Sam is delayed in showing up).

Dean lines Jack up in front of the door. “Now remember,” he says. “Pain is just weakness leaving the body. On three.” He hits the cuffs on the two count, of course. The resulting explosion blasts Jack right through the door. They’re free, at least for the moment.

Down to the control room they go, where Dean takes a hammer and hits the Reset button (wasn’t he going to hit the Standby button?). The red emergency lighting and klaxon come on. When Dean and Jack enter the library, they find Sam alone. The problem appears to be solved.

But it’s not. In the control room, the panel rattles and the sigils above the doors begin to glow an angry red. A steam pipe bursts. Through the steam Mrs. Butters materializes with glowing green eyes and walks back upstairs. There, she TK’s all three of TFW 2.0 (present) across the room and starts to scream at them that she’s not going to fail again. She especially directs her anger at Jack. She says about him that the reason she can’t go back to her forest is “because of things like that!”

Sam tries to talk her down, saying that Sinclair (“Mr. Cuthbert”) used and tortured her. But it’s Dean who gets through to her. He says that Jack “can save the world.” He points out that that’s always been “the mission.” Confused, Mrs. Butters stands down. The emergency lighting cuts out and everything in the Bunker goes back to normal.

Afterward, she heals Sam’s hand and apologizes to all three of them. Jack says it’s okay. When Sam and Dean note that Sinclair made her leave her forest, she gets all nostalgic about it. Jack then says, “It’s settled.” The next moment, we see her in travel clothes with a purse, as she’s going back home.

She warns them that without her magic, “the Bunker will revert to Standby mode.” Dean tries to make the best of it, talking about the big telescope in the alcove. She tells him it’s not a telescope. It’s an interdimensional geoscope (in other words, a scope that can look into other worlds in the Multiverse).

When Dean comments that he’s looked in it and not seen anything, Mrs. Butters says, “Ohh. Oh, that’s not good.” (Obviously, this is a reference to all the other worlds Chuck was destroying and indicates there was nothing to see in the scope because there are no more worlds left in the Multiverse.)

Jack gives her the photo of the Men of Letters that was on the wall. Before she leaves, she tells Dean to eat his vegetables, Sam to cut his hair, and Jack to go save the world. The she snaps her fingers and vanishes. Half the Bunker shuts down, including half the lights.

Later, while they are reading or doing research or something in the library, Sam tries to get Jack to open up. Jack admits that here he is, supposed to kill God, and he got taken down by a wood nymph. He’s not at all sure he is up to the job. Sam says that he has to because he’s “the only one who can.” (ugh)

Dean breaks up the mood by coming in with a cake, wearing his apron (which Sam continues to be salty about, for some unknown reason). It’s a birthday cake for Jack. Dean has decided that Mrs. Butters was right – even though they’re busy, they should still celebrate occasions. Dean admits that the cake doesn’t look perfect the way Mrs. Butters would have made it, but Jack is happy to see it, nonetheless. Dean lights a candle and puts it on the cake. Sam tells Jack to make a wish. Jack sits for a moment, thinking, then blows the candle out.


Ratings for this new episode rose from those for the previous episode to 0.4/3 in the A18-49 demo and 1.1 million.

Review: When I first saw the commentary about this episode on Twitter, I was sure I was going to hate it. It sounded quite bad and like an entire forty-some minutes of Jacknatural. After I saw it, though, my feelings became more … mixed. I still actively disliked the Jacknatural aspect, and there were some seriously problematical things, like the entire treatment of what was effectively the Brothers’ condoning their predecessors’ enslavement and torture of a sentient supernatural being.

And yet, the entire montage of Sam and Dean hunting and being ministered to by Mrs. Butters, to the tune of “Cleanin’ Up the Town” from Ghostbusters (a decent non-soundtrack song, for once), was magic. Dean’s enthusiasm over the whole idea of having endless birthdays and Christmas and Halloween was magic. I will probably end up rewatching this montage a good bit come Christmastime.

I actually liked Mrs. Butters and felt sorry for her, far more than Jack (in fact, I think she had some excellent points about Jack). And I know I wasn’t supposed to laugh at Dean beating the hell out of Jack to get them out of the dungeon, but I totally did and I’m not sorry. If that’s all Jack has to suffer from Mary’s loved ones for killing her, it’ll be the very, very least he deserves.

I am thoroughly over and stick-a-fork-in-me done with Jacknatural. Any bit of taking him down a peg introduces some welcome balance to the show that it really needs at this point.

The show has made it seem as though Jack getting his soul back should somehow alleviate what he did to Mary, but I don’t see how something that he was basically tricked into doing should be redemptive in any real way. Mary is no less dead and Jack, for all his guilt, hasn’t done much at all to make amends. There are only so many times you can apologize before you realize that “sorry” is just a word without actions to back it up. This is not Jack’s first “Ooh, I made a really cosmic boo-boo” rodeo and his learning curve is distressing flat throughout.

I also thought his unsympathetic reaction to the old film was un-reassuring. The monsters Mrs. Butters was helping Sam and Dean hunt may or may not have been worthy of killing, but we’ve seen that the Thule invariably are. Jack also didn’t pick up at all on the many hints Sinclair gave that he had tortured Mrs. Butters into serving the Men of Letters. In that moment, he had no compassion for her and hypocritically saw her as nothing more than a monster.

The weird thing is that for all the gaslighting of Dean in-story for not forgiving Jack ridiculously soon, Dean’s the only one of TFW who is acting in character. I don’t even know what the hell Castiel is supposed to be responding to, anymore (he lost most of his remaining personality when Jack brainwashed him from the womb in Season 12). But what about Sam? There’s sort-of, kind-of some supporting canon for Sam acting so academically about Mary’s death and Jack’s role in it. He did admit in the Pilot that he didn’t remember Mary, so he lacked the primal emotional connection to her that Dean had.

Later, we saw Sam react in a similarly muted way to John’s death. Those two had a lot of mixed feelings toward each other, so I guess that makes sense. Anyhoo, it’s canon that Dean reacted a lot more violently to John’s death than Sam did.

But then there’s the flip side of this coin. In the very same Pilot episode, Sam swore vengeance for his girlfriend Jessica’s death and went on a roaring rampage of revenge, as The Bride might have put it. Even five seasons later, when he find out a demon possessed his close friend and then murdered Jessica just to put him on that road, Sam thoroughly enjoyed gutting Brady like a fish. He went completely off the rails after Lilith and then Metatron killed Dean. He had an incandescent hatred for Crowley after Crowley murdered Sarah, one that combined with Sam’s irrational jealousy every time Dean forms strong relationships with other men, that ended up in a situation where Sam threatened the entire Multiverse.

Sam’s been a lot of things, but he ain’t Spock. Either he never did develop strong feelings for his mother, despite extensive attempts by the writers in the past few seasons to show them bonding, or he’s been brainwashed like Castiel, or he’s lying to Jack’s face about forgiving him and just using him to take out Chuck.

The episode dealt clumsily with the central idea of Mrs. Butters as an enslaved supernatural being who powered the Bunker to an extra level. It doesn’t help that the name pretty obviously (though anachronistically) evokes the brand name Mrs. Butterworth, a famous American syrup brand. Rumor has it that Mrs. Butterworth was originally inspired by Hattie McDaniel’s enslaved house servant and nanny in Gone with the Wind (1939), though the brand wasn’t introduced until 1961. Its packaging has recently been revamped after criticism that the original model evoked “mammy” stereotypes. I talked a bit about that stereotype (most famously illustrated by McDaniel’s role, albeit much older) in my review of season one’s “Home,” since Missouri definitely evoked it.

While Mrs. Butters has a British accent, and it’s implied that she was originally German (Hyacinth Bucket meets the hausfrau stereotype), her name seems a pretty obvious evocation of the above minstrel show trope, as well. Whatever “Last Holiday” was trying to say about slavery seems to get tangled up in a lot of white-washed, tone-deaf Lost Cause subtext as the Brothers and Jack proceed to enjoy Mrs. Butters’ ministrations without thinking too hard about what she gets out of it. It made me wonder what other dark secrets and beings might be involved in the Bunker’s foundations. Cuthbert Sinclair really was quite the bastard, wasn’t he?

The frequently perky tone didn’t necessarily help. For example, the only time Dean appeared to take Mrs. Butters seriously as a threat was near the end, when he finally got through to her by explaining Jack’s actual function with them. While the way Mrs. Butters then stood down may seem heartwarming on the surface, I was struck by the bleak (unintended?) subtext that only when Dean pointed out that Jack was a Men of Letters weapon (like her) did she back off.

Was it because she just didn’t buy that the Brothers considered Jack family, especially after what he’d done to their mother? Or was it because Dean was finally being honest when he made it clear that Jack was a weapon and that he and Sam knew exactly what they were doing in keeping him in the Bunker (as she implied when she locked Jack in the dungeon)? Had she previously been reacting to the underlying dishonesty?

By the way, if the name Henshaw sounds familiar, he’s the Man of Letters who wrote the report about the Hand of God in Season 11’s “The Vessel.” So, think of Jack as a sentient Hand of God. Then he doesn’t seem quite so special as he thinks.

It actually makes a lot of sense that Mrs. Butters would take special umbrage to Jack. It’s necessary to remind everyone here that Jack didn’t just kill Mary. He also killed his own mother by being born. Jack is a natural born matricide, twice over. That the show had Kelly gloss over this, even in Heaven (ugh, gag), and make it seem okay didn’t improve matters.

But Mrs. Butters is a maternal figure herself, nurturing full-grown men engaged in a very dangerous profession. She would relate to other maternal figures, the real mothers of these men, more than some other characters. And she would find matricide especially unforgivable. After all, it’s a direct threat to her, as well.

I didn’t notice until the rewatch that Dean did actually free her right away. It was off-hand and he was basically evicting her from her home of three-quarters of a century, but his very first thought was not to take advantage of her, as was the impression I got on first watch. After all, he had been tortured by Cuthbert Sinclair and nearly made his slave, too.

It wasn’t until she clearly showed her intent and desire to remain in the Bunker that Dean started to get into keeping her around. Keep in mind that Sam’s very first thought was to kill her, though he eventually warmed to her, as well, and we got to see a happier Sam for a while (sad we didn’t get to see Eileen this time, though).

Perhaps the biggest problem with the suspension of disbelief here is that the episode chose to introduce and write out a key element in the Bunker’s history inside a single episode. Mrs. Butters was a lot like that Hunter character the Brothers have supposedly known for decades (but never mentioned before) who pops up for a single episode, only to get killed off (usually after having turned evil, first). I think we might have felt the sense of betrayal a bit more when she turned on them if she had been introduced at least a few episodes earlier.

Alas, with introducing such a powerful figure, so intimately connected to the Bunker, this late in the game, retcons and other questions arose. For example, when Amara invaded the Bunker near the end of season 11 and burned out the sigils in the walls, why wasn’t Mrs. Butters awakened or even killed? What about when Dorothy brought the Witch into the Bunker? Was Mrs. Butters not there, yet? Why didn’t the Brothers ever notice the control room in their thorough search of the place? Did none of the Men of Letters notice that early on that Cuthbert Sinclair never seemed to age? Were the London Men of Letters ever aware of her existence? How long a timespan did this episode even cover?

Why introduce such a powerful character (she took down Jack) so late in the game and then write her out? Is not Earth Prime her home, her woods, writ large? Couldn’t the Brothers use her as an ally against Chuck, instead of the show writers’ usual simplistic obsession with a single solution (finding and neutralizing/recruiting Amara) that we already know won’t work in the breach? I know the Nazis were obsessed with nature, but is her grove even still standing? What happens if/when she finds out it’s not? Will she turn monstrous?

Why are we even still doing MOTWs at this late date? Are all of these elements in the last seven episodes going to figure in the finale? I hope so, but they need to hurry up with starting to tie them together.

Next week: Gimme Shelter: Castiel’s back and the Brothers going looking for Amara. I’m sure that will end well.

The Kripke Years

Season 1

Season 2

Season 3

Season 4

Season 5

The Gamble Years

Season 6 (with Kripke)

Season 7

The Carver Years

Season 8

Season 9

Season 10

Season 11

The Dabb Years

Season 12

Season 13

Season 14

Season 15

Like this column? You can help keep it going by contributing monthly via Patreon (which includes perks), making a one-time donation through Paypal, or buying us a coffee.

51 thoughts on “The Official Supernatural: “Last Holiday” (15.14) Recap and Review”

  1. As much as I would like to even enjoy small bits of this episode, it’s so dumb, and it seems to get dumber the more I think about it – especially the ending.

    So, our Michael was so stupid he never figured out that there were other worlds but a bunch of humans did? And they didn’t just figure it out, they built a giant telescope to look at these other worlds? Given that before, the other worlds were only known by ripping through space-time to get to them, how did a bunch of humans build a giant telescope to watch them without setting off alarm bells across multiple planes of existence? Are we just supposed to point to Cuthbert Sinclair and say ‘Sure, he does all this weird stuff, it was definitely him’? And like no one, anywhere, noticed this? At all?

    Are we supposed to believe that Mrs. Butters is so powerful that she can power something like this without notice and the brothers just let her wander off to a forest that may or may not exist anymore? What is a wood nymph to this show?

    And sure, it’s all sweet that Sam still likes Eileen, but how is she doing? I mean, the last time we saw her, she was having a personal crisis since learning that her resurrection had been planned by an abusive Chuck to use her as a spy and to break Sam through torture before being ‘powered down’ in a broom closet. Kind of thinking that no matter what Sam wears she’s still having some major problems, especially since she’s the one that separated herself from him because of all of the above. No mention of this, show? No little hand wave about just why she’s with Sam right now since she’s been used to harm him before? Huh. I honestly thought that the boys were in some false reality during this part, but nope, all real.

    Dean should have gotten that smoothie recipe from Mrs. B. Or just got her to leave a whole bunch behind to feed Jack with false smiles of “I know how much you like them, they’re totally undrugged now.” He’s dumber than a rock, he’d believe it.

    It’s pretty gross that the show thinks that crying and saying how bad it feels to have done something makes that bad thing done just go away. Nothing he’s done ever shows that he has any inkling of just how much pain he’s done to others – only to himself.

    While it was nice to see Dean happy, it was so contrived and torpedoed so much lore along with other characters, I can’t enjoy even the few snippets that were actually fun. Some of the older episodes I just couldn’t stand I can rewatch and find at least some little things to like. Not seeing it for this season at all – it just stripes everything off characters, takes away achievements, and knowing how it ends makes it all the more impossible to ignore all the bad.

    1. The whole multiverse thing was messy, but it never made any sense that the MoL wouldn’t know about something that was apparently obvious to every shaman out there. The archangels not knowing was straight-up dumb.

      I liked Mrs. Butters and the recreations of holidays she did (kept thinking of those while doing the Christmas recap), but I agree that she was way overpowered for a final season MOTW. And the way the show mishandled Eileen all the way to the end was depressing.

      LOL! at the smoothie recipe thing. Yeah…that could have been useful in a lot of ways. Lord, Jack was so much “Hell, no” that last season.

    1. They sure are banging hard on the idea that it is cosmically important for Dean to forgive Jack. It also appears that the only thing we know for certain Chuck didn’t plan is Dean’s relationship with Amara.

      I don’t believe that Sam has actually forgiven Jack. Maybe that’s why Sam is so determined to make Dean forgive him.

      1. That’s interesting, because Sam has been very quite about his feelings for Jack hasn’t he? (not that he’s ever that open with his own feelings) I just assumed Sam had been building a better relationship with Jack than he had Mary, so was in Jack’s camp, now you’ve made me think twice .
        The episode and season in general has been going hard on Dean, skewing things against him that are just normal as if they are criminal acts, such as his grief. It’s legitimate and grief keeps its own schedule, why should he forgive and forget overnight? It doesn’t make him as bad as he’s being painted. I guess from Sam’s pov maybe it’s just easier to allow Dean his head so he doesn’t have to deal with his own feelings?

        1. If you look at Sam’s actions, he’s doing exactly the same thing with Jack that he did with Mary–faking a cordial relationship while holding them at arm’s length. He also gave Dean a lot of grief for not “forgiving” Mary fast enough, either, yet Dean’s the one who was close to Mary in the first place and who has actually shown grief over her. Dean was the one reaching out to her via text and playing phone games with her (literal phone games. Pictionary and such) while she was on walkabout in season 12. And we all saw how little Sam mourned Mary. I mean, Sam may not be very demonstrative when it comes to compassion and affection, but if he’s jealous, envious, or vengeful? Everybody knows.

          The thing is that while Sam may look “reasonable” on the surface, he’s been shoved into the background by it. He’s become the judgmental sidekick/girlfriend who can’t actually do anything on his own, so he has to goad Dean into doing it, even if it’s dumb.

          1. I’ve always struggled to understand where Sam comes from, I feel the abscence of the real messy, sloppy emotionally charged reactions you get from Dean. Dean I totally get, he acts always from the heart, good or bad. Dean is the people person that folks gravitate towards, he puts in the effort to connect, even when he’s clumsy or flirting, he enjoys company and treasures those momentary connections like they’re gold (like the long weekend with Lisa , he rolled back into her life nine years later as if it was only yesterday for him, and she remembered him and let him in, he’s that memorable) The guy is likeable and approachable.
            Sam’s only true emotional reactions are always tied to Dean, Dean’s friends, Dean’s behaviour, how Dean feels. In a way he appears to live his emotions at a distance, through Dean . Perhaps it’s a case that it’s easier to switch off or judge , rather than to feel?
            Is it a left over defence mechanism from their childhood that allowed Sam not to see / recall things he should have been cognant of? like in Something Wicked when he was there, attacked by a monster but he didn’t remember? Or is it just Sam is always choosing to follow Dean?

            I’d be curious to know how you feel about IF Jack is family ( Don’t answer if you don’t wish to) because dang IF Dean’s telling the truth this week , I get it. There’s so many reasons why that character doesn’t work as family for me and I never bought into the nougat persona. We are told he’s family, but it’s never been shown properly. Every chance he’s had, Jack’s sought out his cosmic connections, he seeks out his darker side of the family listens too and believes them at the expense of his earth “family” Not that he shouldn’t be curious, it’s only natural but those interactions feel off to me, he’s too keen, too interested.
            Or is this episode actually less about the characters themselves and more about what actually constitutes the meaning of family? After all Sam and Dean’s perceptions from early on has always been different, Sam choses what he imagines what family means, modelling himself on his own interpretation of normal ( remembering the postcard Thanksgiving with the perfect family)
            Dean’s perceptions appear to be based solely on what he knows from the real , flawed people around him.

            1. So perhaps in order for Sam to fully reach his potential, to fully embrace his life, he will have to let go of Dean.

              So thinking Dean is the one who dies at the end so that Sam can come around full circle.

              1. I think it’s pretty obvious that everyone who got dusted will come back. This is a Thanos storyline ripoff and there’s no way the show’s going to end with Sam and Dean and Jack in an empty world. So, Eileen’s coming back and if Eileen’s coming back, she’s Sam’s romantic endgame. Sam ditches (or gets ditched by) his brother and becomes Big Kahuna Hunter King.

                Dean, I think, is going to evolve. The Christological dialogue aimed completely and directly at Dean last night was off the scale. Dean actually killed Death–again. Castiel didn’t just profess his love for Dean. He rejected his programmed angelic love for Chuck. So, I’m wondering what Dean might become.

                1. I totally thought of you when I heard Castiels speech. I’m seeing Dean martyred for the world as the Christ figure, exactly as you said.
                  It makes sense of much of the season, Sam’s doubt in his brother cast him in the role of Thomas. Also if you note the writers of next episode, they set up the whole “why have you abandoned us father? ” speech right our of Deans mouth, making him literally the voice of humanity. It seems like they may close off that story thread. Forget the declaration of love, if this happens making Dean a martyr for earth is HUGE!

                2. I remember ‘WAY back in Two Minutes to Midnight DEATH said he was destined to reap God. DEAN HAS THE SCYTHE. That SCYTHE may be the God Weapon they need.

                  I don’t understand when “I” see something very clearly ONE way and others do another: when Castiel ‘summoned’ The Empty so many people believe Dean was looking at Castiel with REPULSION and I saw surprise, and the realization that Castiel was doing something Dean did not want him to do. Summon the Empty to kill him. I did not see revulsion. I can’t figure how somebody can.

                  Alternatively, Amara is ‘inside’ Chuck now; she is constitutionally UNABLE to harm Dean OR permit him to be harmed. What say you Chuck goes in for the kill and his sister THROTTLES him and takes over (added plus: is back as Emily Swallow not Rob Benedict!)

                  1. That’s true. We don’t know if Death’s Scythe could take out God, but it seems possible if Death could do that in the first place. Up to this point, that’s been obscured by all the hand-waving over whether it’s even a good idea to kill God.

                    I didn’t see repulsion, either, in that scene. I saw grief and resignation. Hell, the guy had tears in his eyes and was too broken up to answer Sam’s call, even though he knew Sam was in danger.

                    I do think Amara will fight Chuck from the inside for Dean. I just hope she survives it.

                3. Dean’s final ascension toward a higher existence would fit perfectly with what they set up in 15.18 (and all the seasons before that). How fitting that the brother who started out as special and different gradually had to make do with being ordinary, while the dismissed and overlooked brother climbed higher and higher up the celestial food chain by sheer force of his virtue and personality. Both God and Death have personal beef with Dean, and an angel and God’s counterpart are in love with him.

                  But I just can’t trust Dabb and co. not to bungle this somehow. What a waste of both implicit and explicit foreshadowing if nothing pays off for Dean at all. We were already burned by the Michael “story,” so…

                  1. I hear what you’re saying. That was an obvious storyline and they bungled it horribly. But rules change when a show nears the end and they don’t have to worry about keeping the story going. And this is what it looks as though the showrunners are setting up.

                    FYI, I know I’m not caught up on the episodes, yet, but I was thinking of doing a brief article on Thursday night so everyone would have a place to chat about the penultimate episode. What would y’all like to see with that?

                  2. That is a good point.

                    It also says something about Kripke to me: on the late MUCH-LAMENTED BY ME ‘still’ Television Without Pity somebody posted the story that Kripke based Dean on his brother and a friend of that brother and Sam on HIMSELF.

                    So ‘of course’ Kripke praised the actor he chose to play a handsome version of himself (I remember in Season 1 I read an interview with Kripke on his ‘upcoming’ show SPN: the article mentioned both actors and Kripke only talked about Sam; I had never seen Gilmore Girls (so Jared was a new thing to me) but I LOVED Jensen on Dark Angel. So I did not watch the show because I thought Jensen would be a throwaway part.

                    THEN I retired from working and caught When the Levee Breaks on TNT: I saw this big guy strangle that nice boy from DOOL after smacking ELSWORTH from Deadwood (whom I also liked a lot). Those last 20m stopped me cold. THEN Lucifer Rising was on and I saw “Dean” do everything he could top to BOTTOM to stop Sam from raising Lucifer. I was hooked on the power of the LOVE in Jensen’s performance.

                    From what I gathered Kripke’s brother was a lot more ‘popular’ than he was when they were kids (more charismatic); it must’ve rankled him to find the older brother ‘here’ again more charismatic.

                    I have better feelings about Sam now. Like Dean never had a choice in his life; Sam was never GIVEN a choice in his life. The only thing that has grounded him most of his life is his brother’s love for him. Like the Lucifer Hallucination in Hello Cruel World, his brother is St. Dean in his true depth (all the times Sam yelled all Dean’s ‘imperfections’ at him were just projection in my opinion) of feeling about his brother.

                    I just want the show to end up with BOTH of them together; I have read many people saying Dean would hate being in Memorex Heaven. I don’t think ASH hated his heaven because he KNEW what was going on and traveled throughout Heaven. I would like to believe that Dean could adventure all thru Heaven, meet people from different times. Find his beloved friends and parents. I don’t think that would be a ‘bad’ afterlife.

            2. Marion, to answer your question, no, I don’t. And I don’t think he would be family even if Dean just up and decided to forgive him, or got bullied into it. Whether or not Dean decides to forgive Jack, that won’t absolve Jack (unless, of course, we are now saying Dean has that power as the show’s Christ figure). Jack making up for his actions and choosing to be part of the Winchesters, of TFW 2.0, is what will make him family. Not before then. Castiel’s speech about how he realized that his happiness was dependent on his choices, not Dean’s, is probably heavy foreshadowing here for Jack.

              Dean’s struggle to forgive Jack is about Dean and Dean’s growth. It isn’t about Jack’s growth. Forgiveness is never about the person being forgiven unless it figures somehow into that person’s active struggle for redemption (in that it encourages them that redemption is possible). In order to become real family, Jack has to start choosing family over power. I don’t think he can have both.

              1. Deans evolution had been endlessly fascinating hasn’t it? Always the true heart of the family, he’s becoming his own man ready to fulfill his own choice of destiny.
                Dean is a rare remarkable character on TV that draws everyone in, in part because of Jensen’s charismatic performance, but mostly because Dean’s character turned his misery and pain into something meaningful asking for nothing for himself. It’s why everyone, whatever their views, wants him as their Champion. The embodiment of The Righteous Man in every sense.
                It makes sense why of all his Dad’s , Dean was the one Jack tries to emulate, what he lacks is the real understanding of the nature of selflessness, but maybe there was a little spark of hope in this episode, Jack’s appearently beginning to re- assess who he is but he’s a long way to go.

              2. Ok so Christ figure Dean where does that leave Sam. Because the story, the show is about Sam and his journey. If Dean is the Christ figure doesn’t that elevate his character above and beyond Sams importance? Doesnt that take the story importance from Sam? I’m confused

                Dean Death x 2 and Hitler. You go boi!!!!

                I’m sure the people that have been cast into Chucks cornfield will all return. For the show it would be a matter of reversing the second they wisped out. My guess is Amaras influencing Chuck. I think it will be Dean getting through to Amara in the end and she over rides Chucks intentions. Or merges with Dean. Who knows.

                1. Sam seems set on course to “retire” with Eileen and run a Hunting school or whatever from the Bunker. Jack either sacrifices himself or loses his powers and becomes human.

                  I agree that Amara reaching out from inside Chuck to help TFW beat him is very likely.

                  1. It’s bad enough.if that’s Sam’s ending but with Eileen? Please. There is zero chemistry there. They keep pushing her as Sam’s love but it ain’t selling. I’d rather Sam live on with Deans dog.

                    Destielers keep saying Cas will return. Dibs on him being the dog if he does. 🙂 Kidding.

                    It is weird that there would be a dog left. Perhaps it will turn out to be important. Or someone we know. Cute that Dean seems to be concerned if not somewhat attached to it.

                    1. I’m not a huge fan of Sam/Eileen, either. Eileen started off as a great character who did have chemistry with Sam–until they reduced her to Just Another Love Interest. But they definitely seem headed in that direction. I get that the show has been lurching from plot to plot without a whole lot of organic growth during the Dabb Era, but having Sam hook up permanently with Eileen and reconcile his “retiring” from Hunting with transforming it into a more, shall we say, life-friendly profession, has been telegraphed since at least the beginning of Season 14.

                      As for Dean becoming Death/God, Sam already lampshaded that possibility and all the candidates for replacing Chuck have one thing in common–they learned their best instincts and lessons from Dean. So, why not just go with the person with all the Jesus anvils and the best instincts?

                      The only thing I can think of with the dog is that it’s a play on “God” and that maybe the dog is Chuck, spying on them. Anyhoo, anything to see Ackles get all googly over a pup onscreen.

                      I’m inclined to think Castiel will return. He went to the Empty. We haven’t even dealt with Chuck, yet, let alone the Empty Entity, so it seems almost a given Castiel will play into that final endgame.

                  2. I love the idea of Amara honouring her promise and it seems as if given the motivation and pause to think Amara could get better.
                    It would also be fitting for the show to end on Dean because in the very truest sense he did start it. The simple act of reaching out to his brother to reconnect when John abandoned him set the dominos in motion, so what ever you believe, it’s symmetry if nothing else. Like Billie said “It’s alway been you Dean”

              3. I have been thinking about Jack killing Mary.

                Did I tell you this before?

                Anyway, Jack was ‘overcome’ by a disabling sound. He wanted the sound to stop. Mary kept ‘talking’ and he wanted her to stop. There was a ‘something’ then we see Jack getting up. JACK assumed he killed Mary. I think it was CHUCK who did it to set up the premise for DEAN to kill JACK for Mary’s death.

                Chuck was beginning his orchestration I think at that moment.

                I would’ve liked to see the story that Chuck showed Becky when he asked her editorial opinion (before he poofed her whole family then her) because she was only saying it was not good but I think she would’ve had a shocked reaction if Chuck killed Sam and/or Dean in the story.

                It looked like a whole manuscript to me that he handed to her.

          2. I don’t know if I mentioned this but this episode got a LOT of people mad at Dean for not ‘forgiving’ Jack. I looked back at Game Night and came up with something ELSE: I don’t think Jack killed Mary. I think CHUCK killed Mary to set up Dean to kill Jack.

            Jack had this horrible debilitating sound and Mary kept TALKING to him, saying what is it, Jack? and he kept yelling STOP IT STOP IT.

            Then the screen went blank. Jack came back to himself. And ‘he’ figured he MUST HAVE done it. But WHAT caused the noise which incapacitated Jack?

            I want DEAN to figure this out; I want Dean to use his ‘place’ as The Righteous Man (the One Whose Judgement Is Absolutely) — and we’ve heard Dean do this before — to denounce Chuck. I don’t know if I want Dean to end up as Michael/Dean now or to die in taking out Chuck and having a Heaven like Ash’s, when he can go around and meet all kinds of different people and find his friends.

            It just hit me: CHUCK KILLED MARY.

            AND if I have come to this conclusion before, I should have and if I did I bet I would’ve mentioned it, but I don’t think so, you know? I am always a confusing type of explainer.

            1. Unfortunately, it looks as though the show wants us to forget all about what Jack did. And even if Chuck did kill Mary, Jack murdered other innocents. Chuck didn’t kill them.

              1. Unfortunately I think Dabb wants us to forget about q decent ending. If the series finale is as weak as tonight’s penultimate episode (Thank you Kim M.) then Dabb has really and truly driven the Lamborghini off the cliff, followed closely by Sam and Dean in Baby.
                Very disappointing. I thought Dabb said that looking back we would see all these hints or bread crumbs as to what was to come. Perhaps hes referring to the final episode as well but I kind of doubt it. By dropping that tid bit it made our collective imagination go off the charts wondering, trying to decipher clues… creating storylines FAR MORE interesting and complex that what hes actually given us. I feel so cheated. Sign me up for the 30% of people who dont like the ending and am not even excited or looking forward to next week.

                1. I think it will be a lot more than 30%. When fans are hoping that this week is a “fake” ending where they’re getting all the bad and silly storylines out of the way for the “true” ending next week, you know it sucked hard.

      2. Yes they most definitely wanted to point out Chuck wasnt responsible for the Dean/Amara bond. But then he turns around and claims hes omniscient. One or other Chuckles. Cant be both. Unless of course hes lying – and Dabb pulls more of this writers lie crap storyline. I still think that although they have been united that when push shoves Amara will assist Dean by wresting control at some point ala Sam from Lucifer in Swan Song. I mean wouldnt that be a classic Dabb move? To rip off that iconic moment? Well, iconic for the people that actually liked that finale.

        We all can imagine many different directions Dabb is taking this – some good, some not so much so – I doubt Dabbs ending is going to be half as satisfying as even the worse guess out there.

            1. I don’t think I could abide the return of the dragons, even as fun as Dean breaking Excalibur out of the stone was. They were awful.

              1. Like a lot of monsters, better you don’t see much, SPN dragons were rather lame when you saw them.
                Looking forward to your thoughts on next week when it comes around.

                1. Working on it. Personally, I found “Gimme Shelter” pretty dull, aside from the awesome second Dean/Amara conversation. But I did quite enjoy the final weeChesters outing (which I didn’t expect), so that one and the final episodes should review faster.

                  1. I liked the Weechester saga, it had feelings I’d not felt in a while, like suddenly the show remembered where it came from.

  2. said that some small tweaks and changes had to occur for the remaining episodes this season, including streamlining scenes to feature less characters. It is likely the rest of the episodes will not be as bottled as Last Holiday, but that does lead to speculation on how scaled down the finale might be. Dabb indicated though that in terms of plot and character, nothing was fundamentally changed. That raw, emotional ending is still coming for all

  3. Paula, when did Sam’s jealousy over Dean’s friendship with another male almost cause the Multiverse to fall? Was it when he was always trying to kill Crowley, who for God’s sake somewhere along the line became an ally and kinda sorta devoted to Dean?

    I think a wood nymph may be part of the FAE world, like the Leprechaun from Clap Your Hands If You Believe, and they appear to be powered up ‘differently’ or something. The Leprechaun said he had no fear and would have no trouble going into the Cage with Michael AND Lucifer to get Sam’s soul. I wonder if MAGIC can hold back sheer POWER?

    I agree that we are never sure of Sam’s motives for befriending anybody, just that Dean is usually slower to open up, and then we find out (like Adam) that he is … hey, JEALOUS that Adam was raised ‘normal.’ Well, Sam was not jealous of Adam and DEAN he was just jealous of ADAM.

    Now me, I ‘always’ thought that Cuthbert had performed a magic spell which kept the Bunker always clean. FIRST TIME they went in there was no layer of dust on anything, and that scimitar was still sharp after 70yr. And everything worked, it did not even look like they had to turn on the pilot light on the stove. I mean, a lady with a little feather duster keeping that whole place clean? I mean if she superspeeded it but we did not see that.

    Anyway, lastly, I think she ‘would’ be a formidable ally against Chuck, she would be an opponent he never met before (I wonder if the Fae Universe is a separate Creation, NOT by Chuck?)

  4. You know, I was discussing this with Marion. I think the thing that is bothering me about this season is I anticipated there would be more. More suspense, more urgency… just more. Not their usual seasonal modus operandi. What I wanted was what I liken to the experience of taking a ride on your biggest roller coaster yet. Sure, you’re not exactly a novice. You’ve encountered your share before. But this one. This one is special . Important. One of a kind. So you board and pull the bar down. The anticipation and excitement growing as it gets the better of you and you try to settle in, anticipating that initial lurch which will announce the beginning of your ascent. No stopping now. In for a penny, in for a pound. Breaching the top your stomach drops as you begin the steep descent. Faster and faster, being jerked this way and that, upside down and sideways, stripping your breath away. Coming around the last bend you wipe away the tears in your eyes as it gradually slows, finally reaching the end and pulling to a stop leaving you completely exhilarated and yelling out loud “Man what a f*ck*ng incredible ride!!!” Then you disembark and sadly go your separate ways.

    Now I’ll be the first one to give kudos to Dabb if he manages to pull off the twist he keeps promising. That we, upon looking back, will recognize that the hints were there all along. Ignore for now his remark that 30% will not be pleased with the ending. GOT time. (Though was it only 30% upset disappointed? I’d say higher but that’s just my opinion.) But good for him if that’s the case. However based on what weve seen so far I remain skeptical. Right now mostly all weve gotten has been a meandering and oft times boring story. The show keeps telling me how dire the situation is. Telling me that Sam and Dean are facing the biggest most dangerous foe they have ever been up against. Telling me that there is urgency. Telling me that they are under constant danger. Really? We had seven episodes remaining. We are now down to five (but really only four) before. the series finale. Going by season’s past 16 and 17 will gradually set it up while 18 and 19 will be the action packed, dont blink or you’ll miss it wrap up. I guess I foolishly thought that seeing as it is the last season of the series that there would be less waste of time with MOTW episodes and more focus on the story. That they would treat it differently. Perhaps if they managed to do more showing rather than telling I would feel differently?

    1. Yes, yes Aly, all of that! We need more show less tell, prove to me there’s big threats out there. In Atomic Monsters they looked like that could happen, then we got episode after episode of meh, like we had all the time in the world. There’s a distinct lack of focus and drive.

  5. It appears to me that Dean was both compassionate to Mrs Butters being phased by the impending loss of home which he could relate to and thrilled to have someone care about them to ease his life a little. Dean, indulged himself allowing a mother figure to sooth his still raw heart a bit. Dean wasn’t blind to her servitude, hence his sarcasm but the little boy in him so wanted to have something nice.
    Sam’s very much pro shoot first these days, no shades of grey visible there in his reluctance to give Ms B a chance, he didn’t even question about the vamps with blood bank bags.

    Dean’s weary, low key response to Ms B throwing him in the dungeon was probably because he didn’t really feel that he’d get to keep the nice from the jump, he never does and the whole time he was probably thinking, is today the day it will blow up in my face?
    I think that also given the scale of threats he’s faced and bestest, a Wood Nymph seemed manageable, especially if you think Chuck is the current big bad. Being trapped in his own home was probably no hardship. Being trapped with Jack though was the incentive he needed to take action. Facing off against a Wood Nymph was probably less painful to him than having to look at the person who killed his mother and be stuck listening to him wallow in self pity.

    Jack has yet to fully own what he did and has made it all about him, not the people he hurt. Getting your soul back should tell you to be proactive in making reparations if you’re sincere Jack.

    There were great pains made to parallel Jack, but the closer parallel was actually with Dean, both are basically good hearted souls ( well Nymph in Ms B’s case ) worn down , tortured and brutalised into something they didn’t want to be but trying to make the best of their lot, to as high a standard as possible. The caretaker and protector who isn’t always appricated.
    Ms B also shared Dean’s off the charts reaction to a threat to family!

    Sam has a track record of utilising people to the best effect in order to get what he needs. Jack was taken in with an ulterior motive on Sam’s part beyond saving the world that was tied to Mary, Dean even called him on it so Sam not really taking issue about Mary’s death, being so accepting from his perspective feels more like a writing oversight. Sam’s parental related anger is cannon and he certainly did have anger about losing Mary previously which reared it ugly head , culminating in him yelling at Dean for having a relationship with Mary that he didn’t have with her when she went missing ( Sam, relationships take work, which hey if you truly knew your brother well, you’d understand Dean works at it in a fairly functional way) I think maybe the writer just got caught up in the fun and the romantic interlude and plain forgot , or maybe Sam is over Mary in a way Dean will never be, because he didn’t really know her either go around.
    It was odd Eileen didn’t pop by to at least say hi to Dean, I thought they were all friends the last time we saw her she was stopping over?

  6. i bet my socks mary comes back as a ghost and she and jack hug it out.

    jack: i kill you

    mary : its ok you sweet Nougat you didn’t mean it

    1. I was wondering if Mary might pop up again at some point, but with Sam Smith going through chemo much of this year, I doubt we will see that version of her again in this last run of episodes. Though I suppose they could bring in Amy Gumenick.

  7. Just a few additional thoughts: they wouldn’t suffocate when the air went off in the bunker, because they could just open the front door. BUT…when Ketch actually did lock them in and they were looking through the bunker blueprints to find a way out, they didn’t notice this big control room? (Imagine if they’d just hit the “reset” button then, and not only gotten out without blowing up the wall and Dean’s leg, but had Mrs. Butters to help them–though would she fight against the British MoL? ) Hmmm…

    One thing I loved that you didn’t mention was the lunch bags Mrs. Butters gave them were personalized with “S” and “D” on them, so I suppose she gave them their preferred foods (or a healthier version of his preferences for Dean, I guess.)

    The main issue I had with the ending was wondering if Mrs. Butters could settle for any woods if her own home had been deforested in the last 50 years? Remember Paris Hilton as the wood god saying that her forest had been cut down to build a Yugo factory. What if Mrs. Butters winds up with nowhere to go?

    I also started out being very doubtful about this ep in the beginning, but (sort of) enjoyed it. Yes, it was pointless and had way too much Jack, but it did have the good parts you mentioned. I assumed the idea of “Last Holiday” was the last time they’d have breathing room (and something to celebrate) before the final eps, rather than the last MoW. (And, looking back, it’s worlds better than the next ep, so I’d say find whatever enjoyment you can with this one!)

    I wish I had the faith you seem to that the cast and crew will wring some good out of the ending, but I’m afraid even they can’t spin straw into gold.

    1. One thing I’ve learned from rewatching and retro reviewing old episodes is that a lot of times, a favorite episode is one where I loved the resolution or it has one great sequence in it, rather than the whole thing being fabulous. And I’ve also found that even total crap like “Bloodlines” no longer irritates me as much as it did no first watch, now that I know how the overall story turns out. So, it’s very likely I will remember this episode more fondly down the road, once we find out how things end for Jacknatural. I enjoyed parts of this episode, which is a lot more than I can say for most of this season so far.

      As for the end, yeah, the writers could completely bugger it up such that there’s no salvaging it. But the writing has often been the weakest thing about the show for most of its run, with things being saved by the actors, the crew, the directors (to a lesser extent), and in the editing room. I don’t get pissed off about it until I’ve seen it dive.

      Besides, they’d have to go pretty low to come up with a worse ending than “Swan Song.” Boy, did that suck.

      1. You know, I was discussing this with Marion. I think the thing that is bothering me about this season is I anticipated there would be more. More suspense, more urgency… just more. Not their usual seasonal modus operandi. What I wanted was what I liken to the experience of taking a ride on your biggest roller coaster yet. Sure, you’re not exactly a novice. You’ve encountered your share before. But this one. This one is special . Important. One of a kind. So you board and pull the bar down. The anticipation and excitement growing as it gets the better of you and you try to settle in, anticipating that initial lurch which will announce the beginning of your ascent. No stopping now. In for a penny, in for a pound. Breaching the top your stomach drops as you begin the steep descent. Faster and faster, being jerked this way and that, upside down and sideways, stripping your breath away. Coming around the last bend you wipe away the tears in your eyes as it gradually slows, finally reaching the end and pulling to a stop leaving you completely exhilarated and yelling out loud “Man what a f*ck*ng incredible ride!!!” Then you disembark and sadly go your separate ways.

        Now I’ll be the first one to give kudos to Dabb if he manages to pull off the twist he keeps promising. That we, upon looking back, will recognize that the hints were there all along. Ignore for now his remark that 30% will not be pleased with the ending. GOT time. (Though was it only 30% upset disappointed? I’d say higher but that’s just my opinion.) But good for him if that’s the case. However based on what weve seen so far I remain skeptical. Right now mostly all weve gotten has been a meandering and oft times boring story. The show keeps telling me how dire the situation is. Telling me that Sam and Dean are facing the biggest most dangerous foe they have ever been up against. Telling me that there is urgency. Telling me that they are under constant danger. Really? We had seven episodes remaining. We are now down to five (but really only four) before. the series finale. Going by season’s past 16 and 17 will gradually set it up while 18 and 19 will be the action packed, dont blink or you’ll miss it wrap up. I guess I foolishly thought that seeing as it is the last season of the series that there would be less waste of time with MOTW episodes and more focus on the story. That they would treat it differently. Perhaps if they managed to do more showing rather than telling I would feel differently?

  8. I agree with you that it seemed illogical to introduce such a powerful entity in the buildup to the finale, only to quickly dismiss her. I am also perplexed that they’re still putting out MOTW episodes. I hope this doesn’t result in too much of a rush near the end. Have you heard anything about their rationale in taking this approach?

    On a tangential note, why do you refer to this as a “retro” review, considering the episode in question is rather recent?

    1. Ugh, sorry. Epic copy-and-paste fail there. I fixed it.

      As for why they are still doing MOTWs at this point, I honestly don’t know. They made some noises about this one being a sort of final hurrah of that sort, but then the next two episodes are also MOTWs. Personally, I blame Robert Singer, who always got hives over serial storylines.

      Everything probably will be rushed at the end, unfortunately, especially with 5.19 being the actual season finale according to Jensen Ackles. Series finales tend to be rushed even with good writers and let’s face it–these writers aren’t very good. But I’m hoping the cast and crew will somehow be able to spin something good out of it, as they have in the past.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *